New Books Review

Book Review: New Moon: Stephenie Meyer: BooksCan’t even wait to finish the book to write a review,

By Veronica Canfield (San Antonio, Texas United States) -

  

This review is from: New Moon (The Twilight Saga, Book 2) (Hardcover)

I just received my book in the mail two days ago and I have been devouring it ever since.

The book begins with seeing Bella become very comfortable with Edward and his family. I was delighted to see Alice’s character take on more depth as we began to see more of her personality, but this may quickly turn into disappointment for some, when she is whisked away all too soon. Bella is given a birthday party and accidentally gets a paper cut. This leads to a tense moment when one of the family members cannot contain themselves and makes a leap for Bella. Edward is forced to protect her, but this makes it all to clear that keeping Bella close to the family puts her at risk. Edward begins to withdraw himself emotionally in order to (we readers know what is going to happen, but Bella seems to be in denial)leave her.

Naturally, Bella’s grief is heartwrenching to read. Any girl who has felt the pain of lost or unrequited love will shed a few tears during this chapter. It is hard to get over being furious at Edward’s behavior at the begining of the book, but this simply shows you how easy it is to get pulled into almost believing these characters are real.

Bella becomes seriously withdrawn from the world after his departure and considering their strange and magical relationship, this is to be expected. I do miss Edward’s presence-he was such a strong character in Twilight- but I did something I never do, I flipped to the back of the book to assure myself of his return. Ms. Meyer realizes how addicted her audience is to Edward, so he does make token appearances in a roundabout way. Bella begins to hear Edward’s voice warning her when she puts herself in harm’s way and in this way Bella begins to court danger.

Jacob, the young native American from Twilight, makes a reappearance in New Moon. He becomes a very close friend of Bella’s and helps her through her depression. His character takes the place of Edward and he becomes a major player in this story. He is also the complete opposite of Edward’s sophisticated, wordly one. Jacob is lovable, akward, attractive (in a regular way) and warm-blooded. His story is one of interest and I don’t believe any reader who has already read Twilight, will be surprised at the turn of events in which Jacob is involved.

The book is certainly excellent, as Ms. Meyer is a fabulous writer, but I do find myself impatiently turning the pages and skimming ahead to see when one of the Cullens’ family members will appear. Even with those minor faults, I still find myself staying up way too late to finish another chapter. I have read half the book in the past two days instead of working on lesson plans for my class, during the first week of school, no less. This is a real indicator of just how wonderful New Moon is.

My ultimate disappointment will be when I am finished and must wait another year for the next book to come out. I don’t believe Stephenie Meyer can whip these out fast enough to appease her growing leagues of fans. This is a very desirable position to be in for a writer and this should guarantee many Bella and Edward stories in the future.

*Update
The ending was very good and the reader finds out some interesting information concerning Bella and how special she really is. The twist adds a new dimension to the novel it ends with a bit of a cliffhanger. There is no complete closure for a few important issues and obviously this leaves it wide open for the third novel in the series.

Growing Up, or Lack Thereof,

By syrinx192 -

This review is from: New Moon (The Twilight Saga, Book 2) (Hardcover)

I went into New Moon wanting to like it, and in certain sections I will admit that I did. Naturally I am a fan of Meyer’s previous book, Twilight, and was expecting to see at least a hearty attempt to recreate the magic that Twilight spun in excess. New Moon revolves like a flat tire; the story was trying to get somewhere, but the going was rough, uncomfortable, and by the ending all I could think of was the word “unsatisfactory”.

In New Moon we are tossed into a story of separated lovers, and the book makes no attempt to tone down the obvious allusions to Shakespeare. This is Romeo and Juliet, Edward and Bella style. It gets so heavy handed that in more than a few places Bella is actively casting herself, Edward and Jacob into prominent roles in the play, and Edward takes the suicide plot and runs with it far beyond necessary. I appreciate the attempts by the author to explain just how deep the connection is between Bella and Edward, but the Romeo and Juliet plotline is a recycled one at best, and it quickly grows sour when layered so thickly over the narrative.

Besides Bella and Edward’s love `til death or suicide drama, Jacob Black is a revitalizing breath of fresh air. The newly inherited ability to turn into a werewolf adds Jacob in as an interesting dynamic to Bella’s life (and love life) and I sincerely hope Meyer continues to play with the meaning of what Jacob is to Bella besides a second option to Edward. It would be unfair to cast Jacob as a plainly obvious second fiddle to Edward when he has so much potential.

As far as Bella, while at first her clumsy antics were amusing they also fall flat in New Moon. Bella’s accidental ability to injure herself flies off the chart in New Moon, so much so that I found myself skimming past her new and not so ingenious ways of torturing herself for the fleeting seconds when her subconscious summons up Edward’s voice in order to tell her how to not act like a clumsy fool. There had to be a better way of passing her time without Edward. For one: growing up would have suited Bella nicely. She’s 18, yet everyone in New Moon manages to treat her as either an invalid or an infant, either saving her from herself or actively carting, hauling, or carrying her around. The moment Bella stands up for herself and takes care of herself will be a landmark in this book series, because she spends so much time mourning Edward’s loss and so much time trying to patch Jacob into the holes Edward previously filled you must wonder when Bella can fix herself rather than relying on her male friends to figure it out for her.

By the end of the book, the nature of Bella and Edward’s relationship changes little. Edward comes back, scolds Bella for having acted so insane in his absence because of course he loves her, Bella is shocked that he does indeed love her (although I thought that was already established, and if not why was he trying to commit suicide if he didn’t love her?) and Edward’s still immaturely gung ho on suicide, no matter Bella’s say in it.

Overall, New Moon is a disappointing follow-up. Things felt rushed and ultimately pointless, not to mention the numerous typos found in a first edition copy. Twilight is still a wonderful story, but I can’t say that I’m liking where the story is going.

quick….somebody get this girl a man!,

By Geneva (arizona) -

This review is from: New Moon (The Twilight Saga, Book 2) (Paperback)

As soon as I finished reading “New Moon” I wanted nothing more than to be able to contact Stephenie Meyers (a face-to-face interview would be preferable!) and ask what the hell she was thinking when she decided to make Bella Swan such a co-dependent, pathetic excuse for a character. I mean come on, its only so obvious that many young, impressionable girls are reading the “twilight” series and (god forbid) thinking that they need a man in their life or else there’s nothing left to live for. And by the way, I know some of you are probably wondering why I’ve read not only “New Moon” but “Eclipse” as well, after writing a less than wonderful review for “Twilight” but ill get to that later. First, lets go over the basic plot of “New Moon” and ill tell you why I especially despise Bella in this book.

At the beginning of “New Moon” Bella and Edward are happily in love (atleast as far as I can remember) until an unfortunate event happens during Bellas birthday party at the Cullens house, in which Edward realizes that his being near his dearly beloved puts her life in danger. So then…..*dramatic pause* Edward decides to leave, for Bellas own good (gasp!) and doesn’t plan on ever coming back (oh no!) and worst of all, before leaving he acts as if he hates Bella and informs her that he no longer loves her (is it really so?!) for months afterwards, Bella turns into a catatonic headcase, barely able to function without her beautiful Edward around. She can’t eat, can’t listen to music, and can’t even watch TV because something on it might remind her of Edward. (Rolls eyes) she makes pretty much no effort whatsoever to help herself and let her friends cheer her up, and she might have never recovered if not for….Jacob Black. Jacob Black, aka the werewolf (by the way, werewolves are enemies with the vampires which I just had to mention because I love how Bellas future best friend happens to be an enemy of the love of her life) Bella starts hanging out with Jacob more, and slowly starts to complain a little less about the “massive hole in her chest”….etc etc (skip ahead to the best parts) but of course Bella can’t get Edward out of her head, especially when she realizes that she hears his voice when she is in danger, so then what does she do? Starts purposefully putting herself in ridiculously unecessary dangerous situation, even practically committing suicide just so she can hear his voice. Of course, the vampires find out and Alice Cullen informs Bella that Edward thinks that she is dead and so he decides that he no longer has a reason to live and decides to pay a little visit to Italy, in hopes that the volturi will play a role in ending his life as a vampire. So of course Bella immediately hops on a plane to Italy, and of course gets there just in time to save Edward. And then of course he ends up going back with Bella, realizing that he can’t bear to live without her….blah, blah, blah! (Oh and I do love Edward, atleast until I read Eclipse, so I’m not trying to diss him I just couldn’t help but roll my eyes at his dramatics in this book)

Ok, so now that I’ve finished with my summary of the book, here are some more things I’d like to add. Feel free to stop reading at anytime, really as I’m aware that I’ve written quite a lot already and I’m sure much of what I’ve said has probably angered many of you twilighters.

first, let me start off by saying that I did understand Bellas depression in this book (I just can’t believe the extremes that she took it to) after all, I’m 19 and I’ve had my heartbroken before. But come, practically going into a catatonic state for not just weeks, but months and months, because your boyfriend left you? (And yes I understand that its definitely not easy to get over someone, especially someone that you love. I know this takes quite a bit of time) and not even being able to watch TV? And not being able to function in general, until another guy comes along? (Yep another great message there, girls: remember that having a man in your life is the only thing that will make you happy!) and seriously… are we really supposed to believe that Edward no longer loves Bella? And better yet, are we really supposed to believe that Bella really believes that Edward no longer loves her? Please. And worst of all is the fact that Bella was intentionally hurting herself in order to simply hear Edwards voice. Yet ANOTHER great message for young girls (missing your man? go jump off a cliff and commit suicide and hopefully that’ll get his attention! Life without him isn’t worth living anyway!) and then there’s the extreme and completely unecessary drama of Edward deciding to end his life over Bella, and Bella getting there just in time (but of course) to save his life! Now, I know I may be making a huge deal out of nothing, seeing as how this is just a book, but there are many books out there in which the characters go through so much worse (I.E. Losing a loved one to death or something of the nature) and none of them act half as bad and self-pitying as Bella Swan. Someone needs to give her a swift slap to the face and tell her to wake up and smell the sunshine and inform her that having a man isn’t the most important thing in the world. Perhaps somebody should inform Mrs. Meyers about this as well. A bit harsh? Maybe, but reading these books just made me realize how much I hate reading about female characters with no backbone whatsoever. And really, I have nothing against Stephenie Meyers so don’t get me wrong. I think she could be a very talented writer if she wanted to be (after all, I haven’t met one person who has never heard of her book series) but I just don’t agree with the way she portrays Bella (as you can tell) and I don’t like the kind of message young girls will get because of that.

And as I said, yes its true that I didn’t like “twilight” and had no intention of finishing it, but my sister (who is a huge fan by the way) didn’t understand how I couldn’t like these books, and persuaded me to atleast finish the first one. So I did, and I came to the conclusion that the second half of the book was only slightly more interesting than the first. And was I the only one rooting for that vampire to kill Bella? And yes, even despite my dislike for “twilight” I still decided to read “new moon” because you know what I realized? These books are like a bad soap opera, something you don’t necessarily like, but can’t help but get caught up in it all, if only to laugh and say to yourself “seriously, why does everyone love this so much?”

And just one more thing I’d like to add. I don’t necessarily dislike “twilight” overall. Atleast not the idea of it. After all I like the cullen family, and the volturi are actually pretty interesting. I just think that Stephenie needs to make some HUGE changes with Bella (if only!) and add some events of actual interest to the pages of “twilight” (instead of just Bella describing how beautiful Edward is every other paragraph) and then maybe ill have some nicer things to say about it all.
Search New Moon: Stephenie Meyer: Books from AmAzon

[asa]140566357X[/asa]

Related posts:

1. Book Review: The Twilight Saga Collection (9781905654697): Stephenie Meyer: Books Book Review: The Twilight Saga Collection (9781905654697): Stephenie Meyer: Books Hardcover (Box set) Hardcover (Box set) $49.80 In Stock. Published October 15, 2008 $83.00 $49.80 94 used ?tag=newbooksreview-20″ rel=”nofollow” target=”_blank”>Search The Twilight Saga Collection (9781905654697): Stephenie Meyer: Books from AmAzon [asa]“0316031844″> Hardcover [...]...
2. Book Review: Eclipse (The Twilight Saga) (9780316027656): Stephenie Meyer: Books Book Review: Eclipse (The Twilight Saga) (9780316027656): Stephenie Meyer: BooksA unique book in the trilogy — in all a Mix between vasting dissapointing and tragicly romantic, By S. Lichens (Redhook, New York) -    This review is from: Eclipse [...]...
3. Book Review: Breaking Dawn Special Edition (The Twilight Saga) (9780316044615): Stephenie Meyer: Books Book Review: Breaking Dawn Special Edition (The Twilight Saga) (9780316044615): Stephenie Meyer: BooksHeartbreak of Heathcliff Proportions, By J. Martin “Librarian” (Dallas, TX) -    This review is from: Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, Book 4) (Hardcover) I’ve only recently entered [...]...
4. Book Review: Blue Moon: The Immortals: Alyson Noel: Books Book Review: Blue Moon: The Immortals: Alyson Noel: Books**Sigh**, By A. Jackson (Southern California) -    I didn’t hate it but I didn’t love it either. When I was finished reading the book I was left feeling empty handed. I felt that there could have been more [...]...
5. Book Review: Any Minute: Joyce Meyer: Books Book Review: Any Minute: Joyce Meyer: BooksBoring, By mrfun (Japan) - This review is from: Any Minute: A Novel (Hardcover) I kept hoping this book would get exciting “any minute”, but being disappointed. Juvenile foray into the world of novels [...]...
6. Book Review: Any Minute: A Novel: Joyce Meyer, Deborah Bedford: Books Book Review: Any Minute: A Novel: Joyce Meyer, Deborah Bedford: BooksBoring, By mrfun (Japan) - I kept hoping this book would get exciting “any minute”, but being disappointed. Juvenile foray into the world of novels aimed at female Christians that even ghost-writer Bedford can’t fix. [...]...
7. Book Review: Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design: Stephen Meyer: Books Book Review: Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design: Stephen Meyer: Booksa goldmine of information, By Darwin Researcher (London) - This book contains a goldmine of information in 612 pages and almost 100 pages of notes and references. Meyer, who did his [...]...
8. Book Review: Voices from the Moon: Apollo Astronauts Describe Their Lunar Experiences: Andrew Chaikin: Books Book Review: Voices from the Moon: Apollo Astronauts Describe Their Lunar Experiences: Andrew Chaikin: BooksBeautiful words and pictures, original quality contribution to history, By Dave English (Arizona, USA) -       Let’s start with what this book is not. It is not the complete story of the Apollo [...]...
9. Book Review: Keeping the Moon: Sarah Dessen: Books Book Review: Keeping the Moon: Sarah Dessen: BooksAppreciate yourself!, By Kaitlin Blank “Katie” (Vancouver, BC) -    This review is from: Keeping the Moon (Paperback) Coli (short for Nicole) has a famous mother, who showed women around the country that [...]...
10. Book Review: Rocket Men: The Epic Story of the First Men on the Moon: Craig Nelson: Books Book Review: Rocket Men: The Epic Story of the First Men on the Moon: Craig Nelson: BooksRemembering Apollo 11 after Forty Years, By Jan Peczkis “Scholar and Thinker” (Chicago IL, USA) - (TOP 500 REVIEWER)    The Apollo 11 astronauts, Armstrong, Collins, and Aldrin, realized that the hopes, dreams, [...]...