Book Review: Basic Algebra II: Second Edition (9780486471877): Nathan Jacobson: Books
Book Review: Basic Algebra II: Second Edition (9780486471877): Nathan Jacobson: Books
This book made me an algebraist,
By Richard P. Edwards (Santa Barbara, CA United States) -
This review is from: Basic Algebra I (Bk. 1) (Hardcover)
I mean it: 5 stars — I can think of few books I’d rate as highly. But one warning: This book suits my taste for essay-like exposition, an approach diametrically opposed to the more common practice of tables of numbered theorems and symbol-only proofs. If you prefer to think of a module as a homomorphism from a ring into the ring of endomorphisms of an Abelian group, this book is the right approach; if you prefer a list of equations defining a module, then do not use this book as your primary source. Few mathematicians have a good sense of language, but the comma splices, absent articles, poor syntax, near-aphasia, and sentence-fear prevalent in many texts are absent here. If you are writing for human beings, your text need not obey Fortran syntax, as does Hungerford’s. Jacobson can write. In English.
The chapter on Galois theory covers more finite Galois theory than most algebraists need to know. Jacobson’s style of merging the necessary symbolism into an essay-like presentation is strongest in this long chapter, and planted concepts firmly in my mind in the same language that I would use to describe them in conversation.
But mathematics is not learned through conversation, and that is the crux of the objections to this book. I’m grateful that my undergraduate professor used this book, but I would not recommend doing so, as some good students do not read it easily. I’d use this as a secondary text, with Hungerford, Fraleigh, or Herstein as the primary source. Mathematical writing would be better if all students saw Jacobson’s approach at some point in their careers, Jacobson is the best exponent of terse, clean, textbook-as-essay style. Should you dislike his approach, exposure to his style might still broaden your ideas on mathematical exposition and help you better define your own style; a reaction against his methods can sharpen your own game.
A masterful book.
the best intro to algebra for future mathematicians,
By mathwonk -
This review is from: Basic Algebra I (Bk. 1) (Hardcover)
This book is by an expert algebraist who has rewritten his earlier introduction to algebra from the experience gained after 20 years as a Yale professor. It contains correct insightful proofs, carefully explained as clearly as possible without compromising their goal of reaching the bottom of each topic.
Other books say that one cannot square the circle with ruler and compass because it would require solving an algebraic equation with rational coefficients whose root is pi, and after all pi is a transcendental number. But Jacobson also proves that pi is a transcendental number, so as not to leave a logical gap. Naturally the burden on the student is somewhat higher than if he is merely told this fact without proof.
It is true that some other books include many more examples, and discuss them at extreme length, whereas Jacobson’s book is less than 500 pages, hence cannot include as many words. But Jacobson’s words are sometimes far better chosen, as he clearly understands the material at greater depth than other authors.
In his introduction to R modules, he discusses the most natural possible ring that acts on an abelian group: the ring of its endomorphisms. This is the true motivation behind the usefulness of R modules structures but is not even hinted at in most other books.
In his treatment of factorization in Noetherian domains, Jacobson carefully proves the existence of a single irredudible factor before proving existence of a complete factorization, thus avoiding perfectly a logical trap that some authors do not even notice.
In his discussion of the structure theory of finitely generated modules over a pid, he gives the concrete proof using diagonalization of matrices, that will actually be applied later to linear transformations, rather than some abstract existence proof that will be useless later, as many other authors do.
This sort of careful attention to the internal structure of the subject, and expert skill at presenting it correctly and clearly, are possible only to someone like Jacobson who is a true master of his area. I have only recently, as a mature mathematician, become aware of how wonderful his book really is for beginners who want to learn the subject correctly, from the beginning.
Some students not used to reading paragraphs, have been frustrated at his style of presentation, without realizing the superiority of his content. I can only recommend that those readers try harder to read his book, as it will repay far more than other sources.
Jacobson has made a sincere, and I think very successful effort, to write his 2 volumes on 2 different levels of sophistication, the first being back - bendingly clear and painstakingly organized as to the true logic of the subject.
After choosing a different source for my beginning graduate algebra course, I discovered the superiority of Jacobson, and wondered in amazement how such a great work could have been allowed to go out of print. After reading these reviews I understand. The readers who criticize the experts have eventually managed to veto the use of their works in classes. This makes the market share fall, and the books cease to exist. We have been obliged recently to remove Jacobson from our list of PhD references, in spite of its excellence, because it is out of print. This is a real disservice to our PhD students seeking to understand the material they will need to use.
Average students, i.e. most of us, have the right to learn a subject, but we should not have the right, and we are unwise to try, to vote the best books out of existence simply because we cannot understand them. Let us aspire to understanding the deeper treatment in Jacobson’s book. Let’s put our copy of Jacobson away and save it, if we cannot yet read it.
Clearly it is not the first book for everyone, but it is still perhaps the best, treatment of the material in existence to my knowledge at the upper undergraduate - graduate level, for the student who aspires to real mastery and understanding. If you want to be mathematician, you should get and read this book above others. Indeed the AMA rates both volumes of Jacobson as “essential” for every undergraduate library.
Very good, but there exist better books for beginners,
By Timothy Chow -
This review is from: Basic Algebra I (Bk. 1) (Hardcover)
Jacobson’s choice of topics is interesting; he does not simply stick to the canonical list of topics that the typical "first course in algebra" book covers, but touches on things like Lie and Jordan algebras, lattices, and the decidability of the first-order theory of the reals. For a budding research mathematician, this is great, since these are currently active areas of research. But for the average student, I would recommend something else. Several important theorems are not labelled theorems or given theorem numbers, e.g., the class equation for a finite group, or the fact that a polynomial equation is solvable in radicals if and only if its Galois group is solvable. That principal ideal domains are assumed to be commutative is not explicitly stated, and the notation "E/F" for "E, a field extension of F" is not explained. The Jordan-Holder theorem is not in the chapter on groups but in the Galois theory chapter. All these make for confusion for the student. I’d recommend Herstein’s Topics in Algebra or Fraleigh’s A First Course in Abstract Algebra instead for most students.
Search Basic Algebra II: Second Edition (9780486471877): Nathan Jacobson: Books from AmAzon
[asa]048647187X[/asa]
First tagged "book" by Marcela Landres "Latinidad" Customer tags: latino(2), friendship, middle grade, first love
Related posts:
- Book Review: Elementary Algebra (9780716709527): Harold R. Jacobs: Books Book Review: Elementary Algebra (9780716709527): Harold R. Jacobs: Books Hardcover Hardcover $66.20 In Stock. Published January 15, 1979 ?tag=newbooksreview-20″ rel=”nofollow” target=”_blank”>Search Elementary Algebra (9780716709527): Harold R. Jacobs: Books from AmAzon [asa]“0716710471″> Hardcover Hardcover $66.20 In Stock. Published January 15, 1979 [/asa] ...
- Book Review: Algebra and Trigonometry, Enhanced Edition (9781439047309): James Stewart, Lothar Redlin, Saleem Watson: Books Book Review: Algebra and Trigonometry, Enhanced Edition (9781439047309): James Stewart, Lothar Redlin, Saleem Watson: BooksGreat book, By Y. Sim (Tucson, AZ USA) - This review is from: Algebra and Trigonometry (Hardcover) This math book helped me get into calculus [...]...
- Book Review: Kiss My Math: Showing Pre-Algebra Who’s Boss: Danica McKellar: Books Book Review: Kiss My Math: Showing Pre-Algebra Who’s Boss: Danica McKellar: BooksBuy this for your daughter, By Julie Neal “The Complete Walt Disney World” (Sanibel Island, Fla.) - (TOP 50 REVIEWER) This review is from: Kiss My Math: Showing Pre-Algebra [...]...
- Book Review: Basic Writings of Nietzsche: FRIEDRICH NIETZSCHE: The Kindle Store Book Review: Basic Writings of Nietzsche: FRIEDRICH NIETZSCHE: The Kindle StoreIndispensible collection of Nietzsche’s Writings, By booklover “booklover” (Arlington, MA USA) - This review is from: Basic Writings of Nietzsche (Modern Library) (Hardcover) This book is the best collection [...]...
- Book Review: Burn (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series): Linda Howard: Books Book Review: Burn (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series): Linda Howard: BooksSomewhat Disappointing, By laura cross “jp” (ny, ny) - This review is from: Burn: A Novel (Hardcover) I’m a long-time Linda Howard fan, and was highly anticipating this [...]...
- Book Review: The Perfect Poison (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series): Amanda Quick: Books Book Review: The Perfect Poison (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series): Amanda Quick: BooksThe Perfect Poison by Amanda Quick, By jjmachshev “jj” (Grovetown, GA) - This review is from: The Perfect Poison (Arcane Society, Book 6) (Hardcover) Historical romance [...]...
- Book Review: Plea of Insanity (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series) (9781410417701): Jilliane Hoffman: Books Book Review: Plea of Insanity (Thorndike Press Large Print Basic Series) (9781410417701): Jilliane Hoffman: BooksWonderful, By Mary A. Land (Indiana) - This review is from: Plea of Insanity (Hardcover) I have never written a review, but this book needs [...]...
- Easy Meals in Minutes: 150 Tasty Recipes in 30 Minutes or Less (Hardcover) newly tagged "book" Easy Meals in Minutes: 150 Tasty Recipes in 30 Minutes or Less (Hardcover)By Time-Life Books 38 used and new from $0.01 Customer Rating: First tagged “book” by dalbkino ...
- Book Review: Economics of Money, Banking and Financial Markets (9th Edition): Frederic S. Mishkin: Books Book Review: Economics of Money, Banking and Financial Markets (9th Edition): Frederic S. Mishkin: BooksPretty good book for intermediate level, By Poh Teck Leng (Singapore, Asia) - This review is from: Economics of Money, Banking, and Financial Markets, [...]...
- Book Review: A First Look at Communication Theory: Em Griffin: Books Book Review: A First Look at Communication Theory: Em Griffin: BooksVery useful and practical textbook!, By ”keukaprof” (Keuka Park, NY) - This review is from: A First Look at Communication Theory (Paperback) I used an earlier edition while in [...]...
